Which of the pizza in Whitby has the highest Google rating?

Cosa Nostra, rated 4.6 on Google from 1747 reviews (checked October 2026). Only businesses with at least 10 reviews are ranked on rating.

How many pizza do you list in Whitby?

9: Cosa Nostra, Pizza West, Moutreys, Gino's Pizza, Pizza Figaro, Porto Pizza, Bitz N Pizzas, Domino's Pizza - Whitby and Pizzeria at The Beach House.

Are any pizza in Whitby open on Sunday?

According to their Google listings, Cosa Nostra, Moutreys, Pizza Figaro, Porto Pizza, Domino's Pizza - Whitby and Pizzeria at The Beach House open on Sundays. Hours change, so check before you go.

Are any pizza in Whitby open on Saturday?

According to their Google listings, Cosa Nostra, Pizza West, Moutreys, Pizza Figaro, Porto Pizza, Domino's Pizza - Whitby and Pizzeria at The Beach House open on Saturdays. Hours change, so check before you go.

Pizza in Whitby

There are 9 pizza with an address in Whitby, with 4,497 Google reviews between them. The highest rated is Cosa Nostra (4.6 stars from 1747 reviews). Ratings run from 3.5 to 4.6 stars across the 9 with 10 or more reviews. 6 are open on Sundays.

Ordered by Google rating (from at least 10 reviews), then number of reviews, with businesses that have fewer than 50 reviews listed after the rest. Nobody pays to be ranked. Opening days are as shown on each Google listing.

🍕Cosa Nostra

Hygiene 4/5

Cosa Nostra

★ 4.6 · 1,747 Google reviews

Italian restaurant in Whitby. Rated 4.6 from 1,747 Google reviews.

161 Church St

Hygiene 5/5

Pizza West

★ 4.6 · 622 Google reviews

Pizza restaurant in Whitby. Rated 4.6 from 622 Google reviews.

West Cliff

🍕Moutreys

Hygiene 5/5

Moutreys

★ 4.3 · 868 Google reviews

Italian restaurant in Whitby. Rated 4.3 from 868 Google reviews.

9 Grape Ln

Hygiene 4/5

Gino's Pizza

★ 3.9 · 188 Google reviews

Takeaway in Whitby. Rated 3.9 from 188 Google reviews.

9 The Parade

🍕Pizza Figaro

Hygiene 4/5

Pizza Figaro

★ 3.7 · 261 Google reviews

Pizza restaurant in Whitby. Rated 3.7 from 261 Google reviews.

1 Langborne Rd

🍕Porto Pizza

Hygiene 5/5

Porto Pizza

★ 3.6 · 174 Google reviews

Pizza Takeaway in Whitby. Rated 3.6 from 174 Google reviews.

29 Windsor Terrace

🍕Bitz N Pizzas

Bitz N Pizzas

★ 3.5 · 482 Google reviews

Takeaway in Whitby. Rated 3.5 from 482 Google reviews.

24 Flowergate

🍕Domino's Pizza - Whitby

Hygiene 5/5

Domino's Pizza - Whitby

★ 3.5 · 134 Google reviews

Pizza delivery in Whitby. Rated 3.5 from 134 Google reviews.

Unit 7a, New Quay Rd

🍕Pizzeria at The Beach House

Pizzeria at The Beach House

★ 4.4 · 21 Google reviews

Restaurant in Whitby. Rated 4.4 from 21 Google reviews.

Sandsend Rd

Pizza in Whitby: quick answers

Which of the pizza in Whitby has the highest Google rating?: Cosa Nostra, rated 4.6 on Google from 1747 reviews (checked October 2026). Only businesses with at least 10 reviews are ranked on rating.
How many pizza do you list in Whitby?: 9: Cosa Nostra, Pizza West, Moutreys, Gino's Pizza, Pizza Figaro, Porto Pizza, Bitz N Pizzas, Domino's Pizza - Whitby and Pizzeria at The Beach House.
Are any pizza in Whitby open on Sunday?: According to their Google listings, Cosa Nostra, Moutreys, Pizza Figaro, Porto Pizza, Domino's Pizza - Whitby and Pizzeria at The Beach House open on Sundays. Hours change, so check before you go.
Are any pizza in Whitby open on Saturday?: According to their Google listings, Cosa Nostra, Pizza West, Moutreys, Pizza Figaro, Porto Pizza, Domino's Pizza - Whitby and Pizzeria at The Beach House open on Saturdays. Hours change, so check before you go.

Looking wider? See every pizza we list, or everything in Whitby.

Advert · from the publisher of NorthYorkshire.co

Local business owner? Get an AI workforce, installed for you.

I'm Dean, based in Horndean. I install AI agents that do the jobs your team does at a computer: answering enquiries, chasing quotes and leads, admin and follow-ups. Done for you, in the tools you already use. Not software you're left to figure out.

Enquiries answeredQuotes chasedAdmin & data entryFollow-upsReporting

See what AI could take off your plate

A free call. You'll leave with a plan you can use, with or without me.

Book my free call →

Free · no obligation · UK-wide