We pulled the live Google rating and review count for all the pizza places in Whitby (checked 4 October 2026), ranked on rating first and review count to break ties. Every figure below is real and correct at the time of writing. Nobody paid to be on this list, and ratings move, so a quick check before you go is worthwhile.
How we ranked them: highest Google star rating first, ties broken by number of reviews. 1 of these have fewer than 50 reviews, so they are listed after the better-evidenced ones.
NorthYorkshire.co branded rating card (no business photo used)
Cosa Nostra
Known for portion sizes
With 4.6 stars from 1,747 Google reviews, Cosa Nostra is rated highly by the people who have used it. It is listed in Whitby as an italian restaurant. Reviewers most often mention portion sizes (38 mentions), mussels and sticky toffee pudding. Its Food Standards Agency hygiene rating is 4 out of 5 (last rated March 2025). According to its Google listing: open Monday to Sunday 5–11 pm.
Good to know: phone 01947 602030, has a website with more detail.
Photo: from the business’s Google Maps listing
Pizza West
Known for pizza
Google reviewers rate Pizza West 4.6 out of 5 across 622 reviews. It is listed in Whitby as a pizza restaurant. Reviewers most often mention pizza (184 mentions), bar seating and burrata. Its Food Standards Agency hygiene rating is 5 out of 5 (last rated October 2025). According to its Google listing: open Tuesday to Friday 4–9:30 pm, Saturday 12–9:30 pm; closed Monday and Sunday.
Good to know: phone 01947 604789, has a website with more detail.
NorthYorkshire.co branded rating card (no business photo used)
Moutreys
Known for garlic bread
Moutreys is rated 4.3 from 868 Google reviews. It is listed in Whitby as an italian restaurant. Reviewers most often mention garlic bread (28 mentions), mezzanine seating and wood fired oven. Its Food Standards Agency hygiene rating is 5 out of 5 (last rated June 2025). According to its Google listing: open Monday to Sunday 5–9 pm.
Good to know: phone 01947 602751, has a website with more detail.
Photo: from the business’s Google Maps listing
Gino's Pizza
Known for pizza
With 3.9 stars from 188 Google reviews, Gino's Pizza is rated highly by the people who have used it. It is listed in Whitby as a takeaway. Reviewers most often mention pizza (25 mentions), kebab and chips. Its Food Standards Agency hygiene rating is 4 out of 5 (last rated January 2025).
Good to know: phone 01947 606933, has a website with more detail.
NorthYorkshire.co branded rating card (no business photo used)
Pizza Figaro
Known for kebab
Google reviewers rate Pizza Figaro 3.7 out of 5 across 261 reviews. It is listed in Whitby as a pizza restaurant. Reviewers most often mention kebab (21 mentions), parmesan and cash only. Its Food Standards Agency hygiene rating is 4 out of 5 (last rated October 2025). According to its Google listing: open Monday to Thursday 4–11:45 pm, Friday 4:30 pm–12 am, Saturday 12:30–4 am, 4:30 pm–12 am, Sunday 12:30–4 am, 4–11:45 pm.
Good to know: phone 01947 606000, has a website with more detail.
NorthYorkshire.co branded rating card (no business photo used)
Porto Pizza
Known for pizza
Porto Pizza is rated 3.6 from 174 Google reviews. It is listed in Whitby as a pizza takeaway. Reviewers most often mention pizza (35 mentions), kebab and garlic bread with cheese. Its Food Standards Agency hygiene rating is 5 out of 5 (last rated April 2024). According to its Google listing: open Monday to Sunday 4 pm–12 am.
Good to know: phone 01947 820700, has a website with more detail.
NorthYorkshire.co branded rating card (no business photo used)
Bitz N Pizzas
Known for pizza
With 3.5 stars from 482 Google reviews, Bitz N Pizzas is rated highly by the people who have used it. It is listed in Whitby as a takeaway. Reviewers most often mention pizza (79 mentions), kebab and garlic bread.
Good to know: phone 01947 602020, has a website with more detail.
NorthYorkshire.co branded rating card (no business photo used)
Pizzeria at The Beach House
Known for atmosphere
Google reviewers rate Pizzeria at The Beach House 4.4 out of 5 across 21 reviews. It is listed in Whitby as a restaurant. Reviewers most often mention atmosphere (7 mentions), staff and bar. According to its Google listing: open Monday 5–8:30 pm, Thursday and Friday 5–8:30 pm, Saturday and Sunday 12–8:30 pm; closed Tuesday and Wednesday.
Good to know: phone 01947 661661, has a website with more detail.
The verdict
On Google rating, Cosa Nostra ranks first of the 8 pizza places we checked, with 4.6 stars from 1,747 Google reviews.
How we ranked them
- Which businesses: every listing for pizza places on Google Maps in Whitby with a genuine local address and a public rating. National chains and businesses that don't fit the category are left out.
- Order: Google star rating, highest first, ties broken by review count. Places with fewer than 50 reviews come after the rest, and places with fewer than 10 reviews are not ranked at all.
- "Mentioned" counts: these come from the review topics Google shows on each listing. We haven't picked or edited them.
- Nobody paid to be on this list, and nobody can pay to move up it.
Run a business we've missed, or spotted something out of date? Tell us and we'll check it and update the page.