NorthYorkshire.co
Live
10 OctThe Best Italian Restaurants in Harrogate 2026: 7 Ranked on Real Google Ratings·10 OctDean Keating: The AI Automation Consultant Publishing This North Yorkshire Directory·Ad💼 Feature your business on this tickerjust £5/month →·10 OctChoosing an AI Consultant in North Yorkshire: What an Estate Agent Should Ask·10 OctAI Consultants in North Yorkshire: Who They Are and How They Differ·Ad📍 Get ranked on Google Maps in 2 weeksfrom £27 →·10 OctAI Business Coach in North Yorkshire: Do You Need Coaching, Consulting or Installation?·10 OctAI Agents for a Small Business in North Yorkshire, Explained Through a Dog Groomer’s Inbox·Ad💼 Feature your business on this tickerjust £5/month →·10 OctThe Best Italian Restaurants in Harrogate 2026: 7 Ranked on Real Google Ratings·10 OctDean Keating: The AI Automation Consultant Publishing This North Yorkshire Directory·Ad💼 Feature your business on this tickerjust £5/month →·10 OctChoosing an AI Consultant in North Yorkshire: What an Estate Agent Should Ask·10 OctAI Consultants in North Yorkshire: Who They Are and How They Differ·Ad📍 Get ranked on Google Maps in 2 weeksfrom £27 →·10 OctAI Business Coach in North Yorkshire: Do You Need Coaching, Consulting or Installation?·10 OctAI Agents for a Small Business in North Yorkshire, Explained Through a Dog Groomer’s Inbox·Ad💼 Feature your business on this tickerjust £5/month →·
Guide

The Most-Reviewed Pizza in North Yorkshire

Not the best rated, the most talked about: the pizza with the most Google reviews.

NorthYorkshire.co3 October 2026

A big review count means a lot of people felt strongly enough to write something. This list is ordered purely by number of Google reviews (checked 4 October 2026), national chains left out. It is a popularity list, not a quality ranking: for that, see the best-of guides.

  1. Cosa Nostra: 1,747 reviews, rated 4.6 (Whitby)
  2. Florios Pizzeria: 1,234 reviews, rated 4.6 (Scarborough)
  3. Buon Gusto Harrogate: 978 reviews, rated 4.6 (Harrogate)
  4. Tricolos: 973 reviews, rated 4.2 (Scarborough)
  5. Moutreys: 868 reviews, rated 4.3 (Whitby)
  6. Sapori Selby: 792 reviews, rated 4.7 (Selby)
  7. Florios Pizzeria Ristorante: 761 reviews, rated 4.7 (Malton)
  8. Bianco Ristorante Northallerton: 652 reviews, rated 4.6 (Northallerton)
  9. Pizza West: 622 reviews, rated 4.6 (Whitby)
  10. Bitz N Pizzas: 482 reviews, rated 3.5 (Whitby)

Source: each business's Google Maps listing. Counts change daily.

pizzamost reviewednorthyorkshire

Share this article

Share on FacebookWhatsApp